Brian Urlacher vs. Ray Lewis: Who Was Better?

When it comes to legendary NFL linebackers, two names often rise to the top: Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis. Both players dominated the field during their careers, captivating fans with their skill, intensity, and leadership. But the question remains: who was truly the better linebacker? Was it Urlacher, with his physicality and ability to shed blocks? Or was it Lewis, the athletic, jump-around player?

In this article, we delve into the comparison between Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis, examining their career stats, playing styles, and impact on the game. Join us as we explore the strengths and accomplishments of these two NFL icons and aim to answer the burning question: who was truly the better linebacker?

Key Takeaways:

Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis are both highly regarded NFL linebackers.
They had different playing styles, with Urlacher known for his physicality and Lewis for his athleticism.
Both players had impressive career stats, with Lewis recording more tackles and interceptions.
Lewis had more playoff success, winning two Super Bowls compared to Urlacher’s zero.
Ultimately, the debate on who was better comes down to personal preference and individual interpretation.

Career Accomplishments

Throughout their impressive NFL careers, both Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis achieved remarkable feats and solidified their places among the league’s elite linebackers.

Ray Lewis, playing for the Baltimore Ravens for 17 seasons from 1996 to 2012, had a decorated career that included numerous accolades. He was honored as the NFL Defensive Player of the Year twice, made an astonishing 13 Pro Bowl appearances, and was named first-team All-Pro an impressive seven times. Additionally, Lewis was instrumental in leading the Ravens to two Super Bowl victories, cementing his status as one of the greatest linebackers in NFL history.

Similarly, Brian Urlacher, who competed for the Chicago Bears for 13 seasons from 2000 to 2012, left an indelible mark on the game. He was recognized as the NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 2005, a testament to his exceptional skills and contributions to his team. Urlacher’s stellar performance earned him eight Pro Bowl selections and placed him on the first-team All-Pro roster four times. Although Urlacher did not win a Super Bowl championship, his impact on the field and his consistent excellence cannot be denied.

Player	NFL Defensive Player of the Year	Pro Bowl Appearances	All-Pro Selections	Super Bowl Championships
Ray Lewis	2	13	7	2
Brian Urlacher	1	8	4	0

Career Statistics

When comparing the career statistics of Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis, it’s clear that both linebackers had impressive numbers throughout their careers. Let’s take a closer look at their individual performances:

Player	Tackles	Sacks	Interceptions
Brian Urlacher	1,353	41.5	22
Ray Lewis	2,050	41.5	31

It’s important to note that tackle statistics prior to 2001 are unofficial, as the NFL began officially tracking tackles that year. However, both Urlacher and Lewis were consistently impactful on the field and made significant contributions to their teams’ defenses.

While Ray Lewis holds the advantage in tackles and interceptions, Brian Urlacher’s numbers are nothing to scoff at. Urlacher’s ability to rack up tackles combined with his presence as a pass rusher, evident by his 41.5 sacks, showcases his versatility as a linebacker.

The image below highlights the impressive career statistics of both players:

Despite their statistical differences, it is clear that both Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis had outstanding careers and left a lasting impact on the game of football.

Playoff Performances

When it comes to playoff performances, both Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis showcased their exceptional skills on the big stage. Let’s take a closer look at their postseason contributions:

Ray Lewis

In 21 playoff games, Ray Lewis recorded an impressive 211 tackles, 2 sacks, and 2 interceptions. His impact on the field was undeniable, as he consistently made crucial plays to help his team succeed. Lewis also had the distinction of winning 2 Super Bowls, further solidifying his legacy as one of the all-time greats.

Brian Urlacher

In 7 playoff games, Brian Urlacher tallied 55 tackles, 2 sacks, and 2 interceptions. Although his playoff resume may not match Lewis in terms of quantity, Urlacher’s contributions were still significant. His ability to disrupt offenses and make key plays in crucial moments solidified his status as a vital component of the Bears’ postseason runs.

While Ray Lewis had more playoff success, both players demonstrated their value and impact when it mattered most. Although Urlacher did not hoist the Lombardi Trophy, his contributions cannot be overlooked.

Note: Playoffs are a true test of a player’s ability to perform under pressure. Both Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis rose to the occasion and left their mark on the postseason.

Playing Style and Impact

When it comes to playing style, Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis had distinct approaches that made them exceptional linebackers. Kevin Mawae, a former NFL center, commended Urlacher for his physicality and ability to shed blocks, emphasizing his dominating presence in the box. On the other hand, Lewis was often regarded as an athletic, jump-around player who utilized his agility to make impactful plays on the field.

While Mawae may have favored Urlacher’s physical playing style, it is important to note that Lewis had a profound impact on the game beyond his physicality. Lewis was the heart and soul of the Baltimore Ravens’ defense, known for his leadership skills and ability to rally his teammates. His presence alone commanded respect from both his teammates and opponents, making him a true leader on and off the field.

Hall of Fame Recognition

Both Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis are highly likely to be inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Their exceptional careers and impact on the game make them deserving candidates for this prestigious honor.

However, the selection process may present some challenges for Urlacher. As he is nominated in the same year as Lewis, some believe that the selection committee may hesitate to induct two middle linebackers in the same year. This factor could potentially influence Urlacher’s Hall of Fame chances, despite his impressive career.

Regardless of the selection process, both Urlacher and Lewis have left an indelible mark on the NFL. Their contributions to the game, both on the field and as leaders, have solidified their places among the all-time greats.

Brian Urlacher	Ray Lewis
13 Seasons with the Chicago Bears	17 Seasons with the Baltimore Ravens
8 Pro Bowl Selections	13 Pro Bowl Selections
4-time First-Team All-Pro	7-time First-Team All-Pro
2005 NFL Defensive Player of the Year	2-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year

Note: The above table showcases the career highlights of Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis, highlighting their achievements and accolades throughout their respective careers.

Despite the potential challenges, the Hall of Fame selections for both Urlacher and Lewis are well-deserved. Their impact on the game, their teams, and the linebacker position as a whole cannot be understated. The Hall of Fame recognition is a testament to their outstanding contributions to the sport of football.

Opposing Opinions

While Kevin Mawae prefers Brian Urlacher’s playing style, other coaches and former players have different opinions. Rex Ryan, who coached with Ray Lewis, praised Lewis as the “baddest cat on the field” and emphasized his leadership and impact on the game. Other coaches like Jack Del Rio and Marvin Lewis also commended Lewis for his leadership skills and ability to rally the team.

Despite the differing opinions, it is clear that both Urlacher and Lewis had a significant impact on the field and were highly respected by their peers. The next section will delve into the Hall of Fame recognition that awaited these two legendary linebackers.

Coach/Player	Opinion
Rex Ryan	Praised Ray Lewis as the “baddest cat on the field” and commended his leadership and impact on the game.
Jack Del Rio	Commended Ray Lewis for his leadership skills and ability to rally the team.
Marvin Lewis	Appreciated Ray Lewis for his leadership skills and his contributions to the success of the team.

Conclusion

Comparing Brian Urlacher and Ray Lewis is no easy task. Both players had exceptional careers and made significant impacts on their respective teams. While opinions may differ regarding who was better, it is evident that both Urlacher and Lewis were highly respected and are likely to be remembered as two of the greatest middle linebackers in NFL history. Ultimately, the debate between Urlacher and Lewis comes down to personal preference and individual interpretation.

NFL